Today marks five months since Nancy Guthrie, the mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie, disappeared from her Arizona home in the middle of the night. Now, a law enforcement expert with years of experience working criminal cases has exclusively told Men’s Journal about what could lead to a breakthrough in the case.
How a Former FBI Agent Believes the Nancy Guthrie Case Could Break Open
When the FBI released images of the suspect in the Nancy Guthrie case, who some observers now call Porch Guy, it was arguably the biggest break to date. Unfortunately, the masked man still hasn’t been identified in the months since then. However, a former FBI agent has just exclusively told Men’s Journal about concrete ways his identity could be discovered, which would be a huge breakthrough.
Jennifer Coffindaffer is a former FBI special agent and SWAT team member who worked as a federal agent for 28 years, 25 of which she spent with the FBI. After retiring from law enforcement, she has become a NewsNation contributor and the host of her own show, “Break the Case with Jen Coffindaffer FBI.”
During her Men’s Journal interview, Coffindaffer explained that she was 99% certain that the Nancy Guthrie case will be solved. When she was asked what she thought was most likely to break the case, she explained why she believes that the images of Porch Guy could be the key.
“I still think that the best piece of evidence is the picture of Porch Guy and the video of him, which show everything he was dressed in and all of that. I really think it will be a matter of time before somebody who knows him finally comes forward.”
After discussing her expectation that someone will tell law enforcement who Porch Guy is, Coffindaffer detailed several likely reasons why that hasn’t happened yet.
“I think there are a lot of reasons that haven’t happened. Everyone who follows true crime or the news thinks that everybody knows about this case. But the fact of the matter is that’s just not true. So many people have no idea other than ‘Oh, yeah. Wasn’t that a girl from the Today show?’ Or, ‘Wasn’t she an older person who was kidnapped or something?’ So you have to wonder whether the people who know Porch Guy even know that this incident happened. His mom, his sister, and his relatives may have no idea, so I think that can be a problem.”
Coffindaffer continued, “Even if they do know what has happened and suspect him, a lot of times people will just completely blow that off. They might even say something to him like, ‘Oh my gosh. You look so much like him in the eyes.’ Of course, his response would be, ‘Oh, come on. It’s not me.’ Which makes them say, ‘Of course, it’s not you.’ So, that’s another big problem. People who end up coming forward later often say things like, ‘I always thought it, but I just couldn’t believe it.’ The other thing, of course, is loyalty and love. His closest friends will want to protect him. Finally, there is fear. Those are the four major reasons that probably have caused nobody to come forward. But I think that is the best way that he’s going to be found.”
On top of identifying what she believes is most likely to result in the Guthrie case being solved, the former agent discussed concrete steps that could lead to that happening soon. While talking to Men’s Journal, Coffindaffer made it clear that she believes investigators should be doing more to publicize that they are seeking information about Porch Guy. She noted her belief that the images of the suspect should be everywhere in Tucson with verbiage in both English and Spanish.
“The biggest thing that is bothering me is I don’t understand why investigators are not putting Porch Guy’s face in advertisements, billboards, and flyers all throughout Tucson. It also baffles me that none of this is in Spanish.”
Next: Nancy Guthrie Update: Expert on Why the Case Is ‘Red Hot’ Behind the Scenes
Go to Source
Author: Matthew Thomas














