2018 New York Wine Experience: Chefs’ Challenge (Wine Spectator)

In an annual ritual at the New York Wine Experience, four heavyweight chefs and restaurateurs gather for a wine-and-food-pairing smackdown, and this year’s edition of the Chefs’ Challenge was as raucous as ever.

Each chef presents a dish, and Wine Spectator executive editor Thomas Matthews and another chef face off via dueling wine pairings. The audience members, who taste it all, determine each segment’s winner.

This year’s panel included old hands Emeril Lagasse and José Andrés, and last year’s rookie, Mario Carbone. The newcomer was Ti Martin, co-owner of Commander’s Palace in New Orleans. “It’s not only a first for Ti, it’s a first for us,” Matthews acknowledged. “It’s the first time a woman has appeared on this chefs’ panel.” The crowd erupted in applause. “I don’t know what a nice girl like me is doing at a table like this,” Martin quipped, as she surveyed her competitors.

The pairing portion began with Andrés’ homage to the late chef Joël Robuchon: a rich cauliflower cream with truffle gelatin, pickled cauliflower, caviar and hazelnut oil. It drew a white Burgundy from Lagasse, the Joseph Drouhin Chassagne-Montrachet Embazées 2015 (94 points, $120). He explained that as a young cook in the 1980s, he tasted Robuchön’s original dish. “To me, it spoke French,” he said. “I chose this wine for its complexity, its richness, the buttery notes.”

Matthews went with Veuve Clicquot, a producer beloved by Robuchon. “There’s a kind of sentimental connection,” he said, adding that the darker, richer flavors of the Brut Champagne La Grande Dame 2008 (95, $150), which is 95 percent Pinot Noir, accentuated the dish’s truffle element, “and the bubbles refresh the unctuousness of the terrine.”

When pressed for a decision, Carbone took a jab at Matthews for having teased him about his rookie panel performance: “I generally like to vote against you, just for spite.” Matthews returned fire: “Everybody gets better the second year.” But the audience agreed that Lagasse’s richer wine paired best.

Shannon Sturgis

Four stars of the culinary world represented on one plate.

Next up was Martin’s dish. “Well, I didn’t cook the damn thing!” she protested, crediting Commander’s Palace executive chef Tory McPhail. The cayenne-smoked redfish salad, with herbsaint-infused crabmeat ravigote, citrus, fennel, celery root and toasted pecans inspired Andrés to select a Txakoli, a lightly effervescent, briny white with soaring acidity from Spain’s Basque region. The variety is a go-to for him with seafood, and he felt the Bodegas Itsas-Mendi Bizkaiko Txakolina 7 2015 complemented the dish’s spicy quality.

“2018 has definitely been the year of the rosé,” noted Matthews, who chose the Domaines Ott Bandol Rosé Château Romassan 2017, which stars Mourvèdre, “a gutsy grape that’s got a little more power than most rosés.”

“Both wines are really very close,” Lagasse said, “but I have to say that I would choose José’s wine just because I’m getting the overtones from the smoke much better than [I am with] the Bandol. And for me, that’s the story.”

“Yeah, I’m just over rosé,” Carbone added.

Matthews observed that both wines worked, albeit differently: The Txakoli’s acidity cut through the dish, while the rosé’s roundness supported it. After surveying the audience, he handed the win to Andrés, though he called it a close vote. (Andrés protested this characterization.)

Next, Carbone served a showstopper: a “humble” goose and pork “country” terrine inlaid with Madeira-marinated foie gras, figs and olives, plus fresh fruit, mostarda and pickled mustard seeds. Martin chose a Cabernet Franc–based Loire red, Catherine & Pierre Breton’s Bourgueil Trinch! 2016, while Matthews went with the Merlot-dominant Clos Fourtet St.-Emilion 2015 (96, $105).

To devise the match, Martin had consulted McPhail and Dan Davis, whose wine list at Commander’s Palace holds Wine Spectator’s Grand Award. “You got a lot going on here, dude,” she said to Carbone, “but the olives were standing out for me, and that’s how we got to the Cab Franc. … We got this rustic thing going on.” Matthews agreed that the complex mix of big flavors presented a pairing challenge. “When I am in doubt, I go for red Bordeaux, because I think those wines are classic, they’re timeless, they’re meant for food.”

“This was a humble dish, so how much was your wine, Tom?” Martin retorted.

“Nothing is too good for my people!” he protested.

Shannon Sturgis

Chef José Andrés attempts to sway public opinion at the Chefs’ Challenge.

Carbone voted for Martin as a way of voting against Matthews, he said. But for Lagasse, the fig element in the dish pointed to the dark-fruit finish of the St.-Emilion. The audience agreed, and Matthews took the round.

Andrés was indignant: “The one time they bring a woman on the panel and you cannot vote for her?” he reprimanded the audience.

Last up was Lagasse’s daube glacé, a chilled terrine of oxtail and short rib served with a cracker, apple-horseradish jam, microgreens and mustard-seed vinaigrette. He gave a shout-out to Emeril’s Homebase director of culinary development David Slater and the rest of the team for the dish.

Carbone brought a Mendocino Syrah while Matthews headed again to France, this time to Beaujolais. Carbone said his wine director, John Slover, had noted that the juicy raspberry fruit and smooth tannins of Copaín’s Syrah Yorkville Highlands Tous Ensemble 2015 made it food-friendly.

Matthews recommended the combination of fruit and structure in his pick, Louis Jadot’s Moulin-à-Vent Château des Jacques La Roche 2015 (92, $43). “The acidity is hanging in there with everything going on in the daube glacé,” Martin said, adding with a mischievous smile, “It is towards the end of the panel, so I gotta go with Tom one time.” The audience was with her, and Matthews won the face-off.

Andrés imparted a note of reassurance to those who had voted against Carbone’s pick, the lone U.S. wine of the bunch: “Doesn’t mean you are less American.” The seminar closed with Andrés leading the room in a chant of “We love wine! We love wine!”

Shannon Sturgis

Clockwise from top right: Andrés’ cauliflower and caviar, Martin’s smoked redfish, Carbone’s country terrine and Lagasse’s daube glacé

The Wine and Food Matches

José Andrés, ThinkFoodGroup, Washington, D.C.
Cauliflower Cream with Truffle and Caviar (donated by Sterling Caviar)
Lagasse’s wine: Joseph Drouhin Chassagne-Montrachet Embazées 2015 (94 points, $120)
Matthews’ wine: Veuve Clicquot Brut Champagne La Grande Dame 2008 (95, $150)

Ti Martin, with chef Tory MacPhail, Commander’s Palace, New Orleans
Cayenne-Smoked Redfish Salad
Andrés’ wine: Bodegas Itsas-Mendi Bizkaiko Txakolina 7 2015 (Not Yet Rated)
Matthews’ wine: Domaines Ott Bandol Rosé Château Romassan 2017 (NYR)

Mario Carbone, the Grill, New York
Country Terrine with Foie Gras
Martin’s wine: Catherine & Pierre Breton Bourgueil Trinch! 2016 (NYR)
Matthews’ wine: Clos Fourtet St.-Emilion 2015 (96, $105)

Emeril Lagasse, Emeril’s, New Orleans
Daube Glacé with Apple-Horseradish Salad
Carbone’s wine: Copaín Syrah Yorkville Highlands Tous Ensemble 2015 (NYR)
Matthews’ wine: Louis Jadot Moulin-à-Vent Château des Jacques La Roche 2015 (92, $43)

2018 New York Wine Experience: Oregon’s Pinot Noir Nouveau (Wine Spectator)

“Oregon is the most dynamic wine region in the United States right now,” pronounced senior editor Tim Fish as he introduced the seminar Oregon’s Rising Stars. “When you’re in Willamette Valley, the sense of discovery and opportunity is palpable, and you can taste it in the wines.”

Over the past decade, Willamette Valley has seen an influx of new investment and new vineyard-site exploration, with high-profile consultants and vintners joining the already solid ranks of local artisan growers and winemakers. Oregon has also been gifted with some tremendous recent vintages, earning classic ratings for 2008, 2012, 2014 and 2015. Four of Willamette’s most promising new stars—Big Table Farm, Chapter 24, Lingua Franca and Résonance—presented 2015 Pinot Noirs for an eye-opening horizontal tasting.

“If you had told me in 2010 that I would be standing here today, I wouldn’t have believed it,” said Clare Carver, who moved to Willamette Valley with her husband, winemaker Brian Marcy, in 2006 and founded Big Table Farm. Their Pinot Noir Willamette Valley Sunnyside Vineyard 2015 (93 points, $48) is 100 percent whole-cluster fermented—“We don’t actually even own a destemmer,” said Carver, an artist who also draws all of the winery’s labels. “Everything is naturally fermented, unfined and unfiltered. We believe low-intervention winemaking lets the vineyard shine.”

Hollywood producer–turned-vintner Mark Tarlov was the founding president of Evening Land, but left that brand in 2012 and launched a new Oregon Pinot Noir label, Chapter 24, named for the final chapter of Homer’s Odyssey. He brought on noted Burgundy vigneron Louis-Michel Liger-Belair as director of winemaking and acquired new vineyards with the help of terroir consultant Pedro Parra. According to Tarlov, “Pedro said, ‘There are grand cru quality vineyards in Oregon. We will find them. Eventually. What we need now are wineries who believe in them.’”

While sharing the Chapter 24 Pinot Noir Willamette Valley Last Chapter 2015 (91, $91), a blend of four sites with varied soil types, Tarlov said, “Leonardo Da Vinci said that nature begins with a cause and ends with an experience, so we have to follow the experience, which is the wine, and search for the cause.” He continued, “The magic in wine is caused by the connection between vines and rock. … We believe it is the ‘where’ that creates our ‘what.’”

Fellow Evening Land alum Lawrence Stone is another big believer in the “where.” In his search for great terroir, he looked to Seven Springs vineyard in the Eola-Amity Hills AVA (source of five classic-rated Evening Land Pinots). “I looked across the road [from Seven Springs],” Stone said, “and I sold everything I had; I’m all in on this.” His Lingua Franca Pinot Noir Eola-Amity Hills Mimi’s Mind 2015 (94, $90) comes from another nearby vineyard, owned by vintner Mimi Casteel. “Our wines are made naturally; they’re all wild ferments,” Stone said. “We want the terroir to speak … it’s always the vineyard that’s speaking.”

The final wine came from Oregon newcomers with a Burgundy pedigree. Maison Louis Jadot purchased Resonance Vineyard in the Yamhill-Carlton District AVA in 2013 and quickly set to work establishing an impressive estate. “We had the feeling of a sense of place,” said Résonance head of operations Thibault Gagey. “It was something, being from Burgundy, we are very sensitive to … so we bought the place!” He presented the Résonance Pinot Noir Yamhill-Carlton District Résonance Vineyard 2015 (91, $65), a young wine that he believes has a long life ahead of it. “We still have many things to learn, [but] we strongly believe that Oregon is an amazing place to make Pinot Noir,” said Gagey. “We want to make Oregon wines, not Burgundy wines in Oregon.”

2018 New York Wine Experience: Firmly Planted—3 Decades of a Timeless Biondi-Santi Brunello (Wine Spectator)

One family. One estate. One clone of Sangiovese. Fermentation with native yeasts, 36 months of aging in Slavonion oak casks, two years of aging in bottle. “Every riserva is vinified in the same way,” said seventh-generation family member Tancredi Biondi Santi at Saturday’s four-vintage vertical tasting of Biondi-Santi Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Greppo Riserva. This is as traditional as Brunello gets, with most elements of its production carried through over decades and many going back to the very first vintage of the wine, 1888. The wine even spends some time in five barrels from the 1880s.

Still, as Biondi Santi spoke, he displayed a slide with the credo, “Sharing a family vision from generation to generation with feet firmly planted in tradition with the mind on tomorrow.” After all, as he noted, “We are still studying the evolution of this wine. We think so far it is kind of endless.”

Senior editor Bruce Sanderson started the seminar with a bit of history. Clemente Santi made the first known red wine to bear the name Brunello; the reference dates to 1865. His grandson, Ferruccio Biondi Santi, cultivated a selection of Sangiovese plants that resisted phylloxera, and his son, also Tancredi, homed in on a specific clone, BBS11, that suited the Montalcino terroir particularly well; it is still used to make Brunello at Biondi-Santi and elsewhere across the region.

Since its creation, the Tenuta Greppo Riserva has only been produced 38 times, in the best vintages. It is sourced from the oldest vines in four plots around Montalcino, totaling 65 acres. “Minerality is the main characteristic, I think,” said Biondi Santi, attributing that to the sites’ nutrient-poor schist-based soils known as galestro.

The first wine, the 2004 (95 points, $400 on release), was born of a cooler vintage, which translated to a freshness and vibrancy in the wine. “Acidity, tannins, balance, the structure and the perfumes is really what makes these wines unique,” said Biondi Santi.

The 1997 (95, $425 on release) benefited from a temperate spring and warm summer; it showed a bit more evolution, with spice, tobacco and iron notes. 1990 brought a rainy spring and hot summer to Montalcino; that vintage (97, $230 on release) showed even more secondary and tertiary notes of balsamic, truffle and forest, with the “tannins now starting to become really well-integrated,” noted Sanderson. Biondi Santi still considered this one “young.”

Finally, the 1983 (93), from a vintage with a comparatively early summer and harvest, had come into its own, with all elements harmonized in a “very balanced” structure.

In closing, Biondi Santi said that while the wines pair nicely with roasted chicken (a traditional dish in his family), wild boar or deer, he prefers them on their own: “We call them ‘meditation wines.’” Then, bringing the audience back to 2018, he took a selfie in front of the ballroom crowd before leaving the stage.

Read more about Biondi-Santi in “The Bastion of Brunello,” in Wine Spectator‘s Oct. 31, 2012, issue.

2018 New York Wine Experience: The Universe in a Glass (Wine Spectator)

When Mark Tarlov introduced one of his Oregon Pinot Noirs, the Chapter 24 Willamette Valley Last Chapter 2015, to the audience at the New York Wine Experience on Saturday, he began with a quote from famed American physicist Richard Feynman: “If we look at a glass of wine closely enough we see the entire universe.” Feynman’s point was that there is a world of detail in a glass of wine, from the physics of the tears that form when it’s swirled to the geology of the rocks its vines grow among. Tarlov used the idea as a launching point to dive into the details of Chapter 24’s vineyards.

Speaking to the same crowd a few hours earlier, pro golfer and vintner Cristie Kerr cited attention to detail as the key to success in both golf and wine. “I’m a details person,” she said. “I’m persnickety.”

The details of wine’s universe are what make it great, and this year’s Wine Experience, the 38th, was all about diving deep into those glorious minutia. More than 5,000 people wanting to make the plunge—including consumers, winemakers, winery owners, wine merchants, chefs and sommeliers—flocked to the New York Marriott Marquis in the heart of Times Square, from Oct. 18 to 20, for two evenings of Grand Tastings, 18 seminars, two multicourse lunches paired with the wines of Italy and Santa Barbara County, and a black-tie Champagne reception and banquet recognizing the world’s greatest restaurant wine programs. More than 362 wines were poured from 27,252 bottles into more than 60,000 glasses.

Shannon Sturgis

The seminar ballroom was packed with guests eager to delve into the nuances of each wine in front of them.

Part of what makes wine special is its diverse geography, and the Grand Tastings on Thursday and Friday nights were the perfect place to explore the world. Wineries representing more than 15 nations poured 269 wines, all rated 90 points or higher and selected by Wine Spectator’s editors. More than 2,400 attendees packed two ballrooms and had the opportunity to plan their own education, whether it was comparing greats of Spain or Italy, contrasting Bordeaux first-growths and Napa cult Cabernets or just wandering and finding new things, like a Catalan sparkler or a Japanese red blend.

“It’s overwhelming, it’s exciting. I don’t know where to start,” said Allison Pitts, 25, a New Yorker attending her first Wine Experience. “I feel like I’m learning a lot. There’s different wines from all over the country I never thought I would have the chance of tasting. It’s amazing.”

For Isabel Ferrando, owner of Château St.-Préfert in Châteauneuf-du-Pape, the great names in the room gave her new perspective. “I’ve been making wine for 15 years, and here I am, in the temple of winemakers.”

Shannon Sturgis

Bordeaux’s Château Canon-La Gaffelière 2014, the No. 7 wine of 2017, was among the wines showcased.

Friday and Saturday’s in-depth daytime seminars offered more detail, including presentations of the Top 10 Wines of 2017, capped by a tasting honoring Wine Spectator‘s 2017 Wine of the Year, Duckhorn Merlot Napa Valley Three Palms Vineyard 2014.

No one does detail like Burgundy, and attendees got to drill down into the terroir of one hill in the French wine region, as four of its top houses presented Pinot Noirs from the Corton grand cru. History lovers could learn about one of Italy’s pioneering estates, Biondi-Santi, which showcased four vintages of its Brunello di Montalcino Tenuta Greppo Riserva, including the 1983. California devotees were wowed by six bottlings of Schrader Cellars Beckstoffer To Kalon Cabernet presented by Fred Schrader and winemaker Thomas Brown. Prince Robert de Luxembourg spoke of some of the highlights of the five-century history of Bordeaux’s Château Haut-Brion, while the first-growth’s director, Jean-Philippe Delmas, gave details on specific vintages the audience got to taste, including the 2005, 2000 and 1998.

Shannon Sturgis

A guest enjoys a taste of California winemaker Mark Aubert’s Sonoma Chardonnay from his Lauren vineyard.

Wine is more than history and geology, however. It’s people, passion, poetry and even song. For rocker Jon Bon Jovi, wine is a project that lets him work with his son Jesse Bongiovi and his new friend, vintner Gérard Bertrand. The Bon Jovi family presented the fruits of that friendship, Diving into Hampton Water Rosé 2017. And Bon Jovi shared his music with the crowd. “I’m often invited places, and often told that I have to sing for my supper,” he joked. For winemaker Louis Barruol of Château de St.-Cosme, who shared his 2015 Gigondas, wine is a craft and profession, passed down from father to child, as Barruol’s father taught him and he is now teaching his children.

Shannon Sturgis

Guests capture Jon Bon Jovi’s performance for posterity.

Wine can show us a diverse range of perspectives. Laura Catena of Argentina’s Bodega Catena Zapata, spoke about discussing how to bring the history of Malbec to the world; “I want to tell this story through women’s eyes,” her sister, Adrianna, had told her. Domaine Huët’s Sarah Hwang presented her Vouvray Demi-Sec Le Mont 2016 and remarked how proud she was to share a stage with fellow female vintners Cleo Pahlmeyer and Aline Baly.

Shannon Sturgis

Three of the Top 10: Cleo Pahlmeyer of Pahlmeyer, Aline Baly of Château Coutet and Sarah Hwang of Domaine Huët

Presenting her 2006 Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia, Priscilla Incisa della Rocchetta explained how her grandfather Mario’s unorthodox decision to plant Cabernet in Bolgheri opened the world’s eyes to what was possible in Tuscany. Ti Martin, co-owner of Commander’s Palace and daughter of famed restaurateur Ella Brennan, brought her spirited point of view to the Chefs’ Challenge seminar, joining José Andrés, Emeril Lagasse and Mario Carbone to explore the magic of pairing wine with food.

German vintner Nik Weis showed how wine can also inspire generosity. He shared nearly the entire tiny production of his exquisite St.-Urbans-Hof Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Mosel Leiwen Laurentiuslay 2015 with the Wine Experience audience.

Shannon Sturgis

Wine Spectator editor and publisher Marvin R. Shanken takes a break between tastings to do a Q&A with some of the senior editors about their tasting beats and the wines that stood out to them from the Grand Tastings.

The Wine Experience would not be possible without such generosity. All net proceeds go to the Wine Spectator Scholarship Foundation, which has raised more than $20 million for scholarships and grants for the hospitality and wine industries, including Washington State University’s enology and viticulture program, Sonoma State University’s Wine Business Institute, the viticulture and enology program at the University of California at Davis, Cornell University’s School of Hotel Administration and Florida International University’s hospitality school.

Shannon Sturgis

Pulling off a series of such large tastings requires a team of sommeliers who check every wine for soundness before the bottles are poured for guests.

In his lecture remarks on wine, Feynman concluded by saying, “If our small minds, for some convenience, divide this glass of wine, this universe, into parts—physics, biology, geology, astronomy, psychology, and so on—remember that nature does not know it. So let us put it all back together, not forgetting ultimately what it is for. Let us give one more final pleasure: Drink it and forget it all.”

Three days packed with gorgeous wines and fascinating information are impossible to forget. But it’s true that the final pleasure of wine is to drink it, preferably in the company of 5,000 good friends.

The 2019 Wine Experience will be held in New York City, Oct. 17–19.

—With reporting by Emma Balter and Brianne Garrett

2018 New York Wine Experience: Wine Star Cristie Kerr (Wine Spectator)

“I am a golfer who makes wine,” Cristie Kerr announced Saturday morning at the Wine Experience. But Kerr is not just any golfer, and she’s not making just any wine.

Kerr’s 23-year golf career began at age 18. Her 20 career wins include two LPGA majors, and she has thrice reached Women’s World Golf’s No. 1 ranking. Along the way, she fell in love with wine. “In the early 2000s, we had a tournament [in La Jolla, Calif.],” Kerr said. “And I would play my practice rounds at 6 in the morning because all I wanted to do … was to go wine tasting. Because golf is boring, but wine tasting is fun. And wine keeps you sane, but golf … if you’ve ever played golf, well, you know what I’m talking about.”

Starting with the 2006 vintage, Kerr teamed with Suzanne Pride Bryan of Pride Mountain Estates to create Curvature, a Napa label specializing in Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay and benefiting breast-cancer research. (Kerr’s mother, diagnosed in 2002, is a breast-cancer survivor.) Through Curvature and her foundation, Birdies for Breast Cancer, Kerr has raised more than $4 million.

In 2013, Kerr Cellars was hatched with star California winemaker Helen Keplinger. “We had a kinship, because of my meticulous attention to detail,” Kerr said. “It’s almost annoying at times how perfect I like to get everything. If anybody has ever seen me putt, they know what I’m talking about!”

“It’s commonly misconstrued that celebrities cannot make great wine. But I think that perception is changing,” Kerr said, presenting her Kerr Napa Valley Reserve 2013 (93 points, $150), a Cabernet-Merlot blend. “I hope that you’ll taste this and see the quality in the glass.”

2018 New York Wine Experience: Schrader Cellars Cabernet—A Story of Renewal and Determination (Wine Spectator)

“If you wanted to tell the story of Napa Cabernet over the past few decades, Fred Schrader’s story would be the perfect way to do it,” said senior editor James Laube, introducing the last of Friday’s seminars. “Fred came to Napa Valley in the 1980s and caught the wine bug. … He and his [then-]wife, Ann Colgin, founded Colgin Cellars, hiring a winemaker named Helen Turley.” The wine debuted in the legendary class of 1992 cult Cabernets, alongside Screaming Eagle and Bryant Family. It was an overnight success.

But after the couple parted ways in the late ’90s, “Fred was faced with the prospects of starting over,” Laube said. “His story is one of renewal and determination.”

Uncertain of his next move, Schrader was tasting through barrels of the 1999 vintage at Behrens & Hitchcock when inspiration struck. “I tasted this one barrel—it was like an epiphany. It was unbelievable. I thought, ‘Good God Almighty, where did this come from?’ They said it was from To Kalon Vineyard down in Oakville. Andy Beckstoffer owns it.”

Schrader promptly struck a deal to buy grapes from Beckstoffer and, his new course set, hired talented young winemaker Thomas Rivers Brown. “His attention to detail, his compassion for wine—he’s completely devoted,” said Schrader. But, “Thomas had never made a Cabernet in his life when I met him. He said, ‘What the hell, we’ll give that a try.’ We shook hands on my porch, and that’s the only contract we’ve ever had.” Since then, more than 50 Schrader Cabernets have earned classic scores of 95 points or more.

Schrader described Brown as “the ultimate master at reading a vineyard.” Through years of selection, Brown and Schrader have contracted 16 prime acres of Beckstoffer To Kalon. “There’s a crossroads in Andy’s vineyard that we think of as the tenderloin of To Kalon,” Brown said, “and we’ve focused on those blocks.”

Schrader and Brown presented three cuvées—Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard RBS, CCS and Old Sparky (MM V and MM VIII, in magnum)—from the 2005 and 2008 vintages. Five of the wines earned classic ratings on release.

“The RBS is much brighter, more red fruit, some savory elements but mostly fruit-dominated,” said Brown. “CCS has a darker profile, you see more things like black walnut, tobacco … for Sparky, it’s the most complete, and holding the most in reserve.”

The two vintages were quite different: 2005 was “a big vintage, more modern” and “2008 was really tiny and really hot,” Brown continued. Although Schrader Cabernets drink well young, he feels they start to hit their peak around 10 years old. “What I like is you’re starting to see the savory character, especially these 2005s, you’re getting more tobacco and herbal notes … really complementary. I think the 2005s, especially the CCS, are just in a spectacular place right now.”

While Schrader wines are often described as opulent, what Brown has done, better than most, said Laube, is achieve an equilibrium between richness and elegance, with nuanced aromatics and flavors.

“So many people are trying to make the best Napa Valley Cabernet, and getting to the top is a very, very combative exercise,” Laube concluded. “And Fred Schrader’s been there twice.”

Read James Laube’s full profile of Fred Schrader in the Nov. 15, 2010, issue of Wine Spectator. Laube’s recent cover story, “The Midas Touch of Thomas Rivers Brown,” appears in the Nov. 15, 2018, issue.

6 Schrader Cellars Cabernets